Page 13 The Sun Bay Paper June 28, 2024 Israeli/Palestinian conflict: it’s not about land “Review the historic record since the 1947 attempt to partition the land now disputed by Israel and Palestinian Arabs. That review will find that the modern-day situation exists as unresolved as it has ever been. Something is wrong with the plan! The reason for this lack of success has been stated over and over again: “It’s not the land stupid!” But the world hasn’t been listening. I’ll provide some examples. Alan Dershowitz reminded us that following WW2, Hitler ally Haj Amin al-Husseini, the Muslim leader in what is now Israel, “turned the Jewish/Arab dispute from a resolvable conflict over land, to an irresolvable conflict over religion” i.e. there must be no Jewish sovereignty. Conservative commentator and Jewish theological author Dennis Prager observes that Westerners want to believe it is about land, but that those “who seek Israel’s destruction do so because Israel is Jewish, not because Israel occupies the West Bank of Gaza.” PLO official Zahir Muhsein announced the following in 1977: “The creation of a Palestinian state is only a means for continuing our struggle against the state of Israel……Only for political and tactical reasons do we speak today……” Yasser Arafat admitted this in 1993: “The question of borders doesn’t interest us. Palestine is nothing but a drop in an enormous ocean.” In 2009, Muhammad Al-Muraikhi, a Qatan Sheikh, stated: “We do not treat the Jews as our enemies just because they occupied Palestine……We will treat the Jews as our enemies even if they return Palestine to us, because they are infidels. They rejected Allah……” Muhammad Hussein Ya’qoub, an Egyptian Imam, declared quite simply: “The Jews are infidels, not because I say so, and not because they are killing Muslims, but because Allah said [they are disbelievers].” Radical Arab and Palestinian leadership have emphatically told us the same thing, time after time, through their rejection of at least five land partition offers for a separate state alongside Israel. Some included all of Gaza along with virtually all of the huge area referred to as the West Bank. They wouldn’t accept a separate Jewish nation. The “players” in this drama are the Jewish nation of Israel and the Palestinian population led by Hamas in Gaza and the Palestinian Authority in the West Bank. Unless both combatants were to lay down their arms there will be no peace. I consider Jewish Prime Minister Netanyahu’s comments about mutual disarmament to be a practical truth. He’s repeatedly stated the following: “If the Arabs put down their weapons today, there would be no more violence. If the Jews put down their weapons today, there would be no more Israel.” It’s not about land. It’s all about religion. That means any solution to this problem won’t be advanced by partitioning the disputed territory. Therefore, any hope for a permanent solution to the Israeli/Palestinian conflict seems less likely. The logical question is, how can future conflicts be minimized so that the greater goal of Israel and Arab peace can happen? While reading excerpts from Benjamin Netanyahu’s book, “Bibi: My Story,” I came across this interesting observation: “……the key to achieving that peace was…… the historic peace accords……In its first seventy-two years, Israel made peace with two Arab countries, Egypt and Jordan. In the span of four months, Israel made peace with four more.” He’s referring to the Abraham Accords led by President Trump. Hoped-for expansion to other countries seems to have stalled. According to Netanyahu, President Trump eventually came to understand that Israeli/Palestinian peace wasn’t a prerequisite for accomplishing the broad goal of Israeli/ Arab peace. Trump decided to bring an end to the current international obsession with achieving peace between Israel and the Palestinians. He focused on creating peace talks between Israel and other Arab nations. And he found several nations were interested. Very soon, “normalization agreements” were signed between Israel and four Arab nations. Israel and the U.S. should move on as soon as possible to regain the momentum Trump achieved with the Abraham Accords. And there’s no need to wait until after the presidential election. While this won’t bring the current war to a standstill, a different strategic attitude may affect how the warring parties conclude the current conflict. Steve Bakke Visit my website at myslantonthings.com Last issue’s puzzle solution to ‘All of Me’
RkJQdWJsaXNoZXIy MjA2ODE3